Theories Used to Explain
Violence
Social Learning / Modeling theory
Dis-inhibition theory - desensitization
Catharsis - media helps violent urges to be released safely
Time-monopoly theory - "no time to do crime"
Ostracism - aggressive types are shunned -- so they have little to do
but watch TV
Predilection - aggressive types choose violent TV
Issues in Violence Research
- What counts as aggression?
- physical force of any kind?
- intentional acts only?
- only acts that cause actual physical harm?
- verbal aggression?
- actions against other persons? self?
- cartoons?
- MTV videos?
- How much violence is there?
- George Gerbner says 6 - 8 episodes/hour,
- 80% of shows sometimes are violent,
- violence is directed against women and elderly usually
Types of Violence research
- Case studies and anecdotes - not very reliable or conclusive; e.g. "Born
Innocent," Ted Bundy.
- Experiments: results
- Bobo doll studies showed violence in cartoons can influence behavior
- College students willingness to shock others after viewing violence has
been shown
- Evidence suggests vicarious rewards for violent acts (in media)
increases effects.
- Girls equal boys when rewards are included in impact
- Catharsis theory is wrong.
- The young do learn to be aggressive from the media, esp. boys
- Children can become desensitized to violence
- Surveys:
- show there is a strong association between viewing violence and
aggression but correlation is not necessarily causation
- longitudinal studies show watching comes before violence
- the "Canadian study" shows a 15 year delay after TV arrives before
crime goes up.
- but early aggression is the best predictor of later violent
behavior, esp. when the environment reinforces or models aggression and when
there is strong character identification.
Summary
- Video violence can have effects, esp. on young males esp. with
predispositions or rewards (in media or real life) for aggression.
- triggering effects occur when violence is a) exciting, b) rights a wrong,
c) has high identification with the viewer (only rare occurrences of this)
- It strengthens the belief in some that aggression is justified.
- There appears to be some desensitization, esp. if the violence is exciting
or shown as "appropriate"
- no significant effect for most people, esp. adults.
last updated 4/20/2001