COMM 335 - ARGUMENTATION

Dr. Lee McGaan  

  Office:  WH 308  (ph. 309-457-2155);  email lee@monmouthcollege.edu
  Home:  418 North Sunny Lane (ph. 309-734-5431, cell 309-333-5447)

Fall 2016 Office Hours:   MWF:  9:30 - 10am, 11am - Noon & 1 -2pm TTh:  2-3pm & by apt.  |  copyright (c) by Lee McGaan, 2006-2016


last updated 11/4/2008

TYPES OF FALLACIES
adapted from S. E. Toulmin, R. Rieke, S. Janik.  Introduction to Reasoning. Prentice Hall, 1984.
 

A.  MISSING GROUNDS

  • circularity:

  • "begging the question" (grounds = claim)   

  •  circular definition

 

B.  IRRELEVANT GROUNDS  (using grounds that have a special appeal to the audience)

  • evading the issue:

  • "red herring"

  • "straw man"  

  • slippery slope/extension  

  • tu quoque 

  • appeal to tradition  (unchallengeable authority) religion, tradition, science, etc.

  • ad hominem (name calling, guilt by assoc, motive)  

  • ad populi (to the people)
     

  • emotion/compassion - pity, fear

  • shifting grounds - shifting the burden of proof

  • two wrongs...  

  • ignorance (of counter evidence)  

 

C.  DEFECTIVE GROUNDS

  • hasty generalization:  

  • too few cases

  • unrepresentative cases

  • accident (applying a rule as if it MUST ALWAYS be used)

 

D.  UNWARRANTED ASSUMPTIONS

  • false cause

  • post hoc ergo propter hoc

  • single cause

  • false analogy
     

  • poisoned well ("COMMON SENSE tells us ..." - "INFORMED voters believe...")

  • dilemma/dichotomy ("either ‑ or")   

  • composition / division

 

E.  Language Fallacies

  • emotive (loaded) language

  • equivocation / ambiguity
     

 [ Fallacies in italics are not mentioned in the text ]